• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

ClearIAS

UPSC: Latest News, IAS, IPS, UPSC Online Preparation

UPSC Prelims Test Series 2021Enroll Now
  • Home
  • Start
    • IAS
    • IAS Exam Eligibility
    • UPSC
    • UPSC Syllabus
    • UPSC Exam Date
    • UPSC Results
    • FAQs
  • Programs
    • Prelims
    • Mains
    • Interview
  • Buy
    • Courses
    • Mock Test Series
    • IAS Books
    • eBooks (PDF)
  • Free
    • Study Materials
    • Guidance
    • eBooks (PDFs)
    • Mock Exams
    • ClearIAS App
    • Downloads
  • Toppers
  • Blog
  • Login
ClearIAS » Current Affairs Notes » Simultaneous Elections: Will this be good for India?

Simultaneous Elections: Will this be good for India?

Last updated on March 2, 2017 by Clear IAS Team

The idea of holding elections simultaneously to Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies is recently in the news after it got a push from Prime Minister Narendra Modi. In this article let us discuss the concept of simultaneous elections, its advantages, disadvantages, feasibility, and other related issues.

What is meant by simultaneous elections?

Simultaneous Elections in India

  • It refers to holding elections to Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies simultaneously, once in a five year.
  • At present, elections to Lok Sabha and to all State Legislative Assemblies are not being held simultaneously.
  • Sometimes, elections to some State Legislative Assemblies may happen together with the elections to Lok Sabha. For example, in 2014, elections to State assemblies of Andhra Pradesh, Odisha and Sikkim were held along with elections to Lok Sabha.

The idea of simultaneous elections

  • The idea of simultaneous elections is not new to India. In 1951-52, the first general election to the Lok Sabha was held simultaneously with all State Assemblies. This practice of simultaneous elections continued till the general election of 1967.
  • This practice got disrupted due to premature dissolution of some State Legislative Assemblies in 1968. Lok Sabha itself dissolved prematurely in 1970.
  • As a result, the elections to the Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies are being held separately.
  • The idea of simultaneous elections was floated long back by former deputy Prime Minister of India, LK Advani.
  • In Recent times, the idea got support from President and Prime Minister. President Pranab Mukherjee has endorsed the idea by mentioning it in his address to the joint session of the parliament ahead of the budget session.
  • Reports of Law commission and the Parliamentary standing committee have also favored simultaneous elections.

Advantages of simultaneous elections

  • The cost of an election has two components – one, expenditure incurred by the Election Commission and two, expenditure incurred by the political parties. A large number of government employees and public buildings are diverted from their regular responsibilities for election duties. Supporters of the simultaneous elections argue that it will reduce election expenditure in terms of finance and reduce diversion of human resources for election duties.
  • Model Code of Conduct (MCC) comes into operation during election season. MCC is seen as an obstacle to the government service delivery mechanism. Simultaneous elections may reduce such disruption.
  • During elections, political convenience takes precedence over public interest. To lure voters, political parties concede to popular demands without any consideration to public interest. Simultaneous elections reduce such opportunity for political parties.
  • Simultaneous election promotes national perspective over the regional perspective. This is important for the unity of the country.
  • Since it promotes national perspective, simultaneous elections strengthen national parties. This reduces mushrooming growth of political parties based on narrow vote bank politics.
  • Simultaneous elections bring States on par with the Center. If the elections are to be held simultaneously once in five years, the elected state governments cannot be dismissed easily. This reduces the anomalies created by the Article 356 (President’s Rule) of the Indian constitution and hence, it strengthens federalism.
  • The simultaneous election once in five years provides stability to the governments. It allows the government to take difficult and harsh decision in larger public interest.

Arguments against simultaneous elections

  • Simultaneous elections may reduce the expenditure incurred by the Election Commission. But there is no guarantee that expenditure of the political parties will reduce. Political parties may spend entire fund at once rather than in phases.
  • Center and States are equal and sovereign within their jurisdiction. Simultaneous elections may reduce the importance of state elections. Thus it affects the concept of federalism.
  • Article 83(2) and Article 172 of the Constitution requires that the Lok Sabha and State legislatures be in existence for five years from the date of its first meeting, “unless dissolved earlier”. Simultaneous elections ignore this phrase, as there would be no opportunity to dissolve Lok Sabha or State Assemblies.
  • A government can be in power as long as it enjoys the confidence of Parliament. Simultaneous elections can work only if governments last for a fixed tenure of five years regardless of confidence of Parliament. It negates the concept of ‘no confidence motion’ – an important tool for legislative control over the executive.
  • Elections are an important part of representative democracy. Simultaneous elections with fixed tenure of five years curtail people’s right to express their confidence or displeasure on the government.
  • Simultaneous elections will relegate local issues or issues of state importance to the background. This completely ignores the diversity of the country.
  • Holding simultaneous election once in five years may also face logistical challenges. For the free and fair conduct of the elections, security forces need to be deployed in large numbers. Given the current strength of security personnel, this may be a challenging task.

Some constitutional questions

Elections Holding simultaneous elections also poses some constitutional questions, which need to be answered. They are,

  • To implement the idea, the tenure of some of the State Assemblies needs to be curtailed. How to do it, when the government enjoys the confidence of the legislature?
  • How to preserve simultaneity in the event of a vote of no confidence or President’s rule?
  • Article 83(2) and Article 172 of the Constitution requires that the Lok Sabha and State legislatures be in existence for five years from the date of its first meeting, “unless dissolved earlier”. This makes it clear that constitution does not guarantee fixed terms to the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies. Simultaneous elections are not possible without fixed tenure.

Shekhawat solution

  • The former vice-president Bhairon Singh Shekhawat proposed a solution. He called for a review of provisions of the no-confidence motion.
  • He suggested that no-confidence motion must mandatorily be accompanied by an alternative government formation plan. This prevents premature dissolution of Lok Sabha on account of political instability.
  • But critics point out that, this solution will take away people’s right to elect or dismiss a government.

Various reports

Law Commission of India

  • 79th report of the parliamentary standing committee on Law and Justice recommended a two-phase election schedule – one concurrent with Lok Sabha elections, the second in the mid-term of the Lok Sabha.
  • The report also recommended that in order to hold early elections to Lok Sabha and state legislative assemblies, one of two conditions must be met: (i) a motion for an early general election must be agreed to by at least two-thirds of all members of the House; or (ii) a no-confidence motion must be passed by the House, and with no alternative government being confirmed within 14 days of passing a confidence motion.
  • The report concluded that such a reform was “important for India if it is to compete with other nations in developmental agenda on real time basis as a robust, democratic country.”
  • Law Commission of India in its 170th report (1999) recommended simultaneous elections to Lok Sabha and State Legislative. It suggested that elections to the legislative assemblies, whose term ends six months after the general elections to Lok Sabha, can be clubbed together. However, the results of such elections can be declared at the end of the assembly’s tenure.
  • The Election Commission also extended its in-principle support for the simultaneous elections.

Impact on voter behavior

  • Studies show that simultaneous elections will have a significant impact on voter’s behaviour. An analysis by IDFC institute shows that on average, there is a 77 percent chance that the Indian voter will vote for the same party for both the State and Centre when elections are held simultaneously.
  • In such cases, the national issues and national parties take precedence over issues of state importance and small regional parties.

A case for frequent elections

  • Frequent elections enhance political accountability. It keeps politicians on their toe.
  • Local issues, state issues, and national issues do not get mixed up. Staggered election cycle gives people an opportunity to distinguish between these issues.
  • Elections create a large number of work opportunity for the people.

Conclusion

As discussed above the idea of simultaneous elections has Advantages as well as difficulties in implementation. Solutions should be found to specific problems.

  • The model code of Conduct shouldn’t be stretched too long. There should be clear guidelines on do’s and don’ts for the government.
  • To curb election expenditure, alternative ways such as reforms in the expenditure of political parties and state funding of political parties could be discussed.

There are various ifs and buts before the idea of simultaneous elections may finally be implemented. The Constitution may need to be amended. But care should be taken, such that simultaneous elections will not undermine federalism and diversity of the country.

130+ Prelims Marks is Possible. Only if you are guided the right way.

Join ClearIAS Prelims Test Series 2021.

Take a Free Test

Article by: Divakar Shenoy H

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Share1K
Tweet
WhatsApp
1K Shares

Integrate Learning With Test-Taking!

Is UPSC Prelims your weak area?

Don’t worry!

We can help you score high marks!

Are you ready to practise the right way?

Yes, I want ClearIAS to help me score high!

Get our newsletter

Don't miss our email updates!

About Clear IAS Team

ClearIAS provides free IAS online coaching, guidance, strategies, books, online study-materials and mock tests with a vision that no candidate should be left out of UPSC exam competition due to in-accessibility of expensive IAS classroom coaching.

We write simple, easy to understand articles, but always ensure high standards of quality.

Rated among the best, emerging online test preparation startups, Clear IAS also offers for free, the popular Clear IAS android app.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. nagesh says

    March 2, 2017 at 9:16 pm

    Wonderful info

    Reply
  2. Saket Sagar says

    March 3, 2017 at 8:50 am

    Very interesting points covered from both positive and negative aspects.

    Reply
  3. Vicky Kumar says

    March 3, 2017 at 3:58 pm

    Sir your articles are amazing can I get that in hindi

    Reply
  4. Pradeep Tiwari says

    March 4, 2017 at 11:07 am

    Where is webinar?????
    I dont get any notification. Its 11:07. What is this.

    Reply
  5. Harish says

    March 4, 2017 at 11:46 am

    Very detailed..!! Covered all aspects of the topic. As usual as all articles, it’s nice and informative..!!

    Reply
  6. manjunath says

    March 6, 2017 at 1:20 am

    Goods points are mentioned… I think this is very helpful to students… Who are preparing for ias exam…

    Reply
  7. Seeker says

    March 10, 2017 at 12:05 am

    In shekawat solution, if a plan is formulated for interim government till election Then it will be a wise solution. whats your view?

    Reply
  8. shaista khan says

    March 13, 2017 at 10:38 pm

    sir plz provide me in hindi all sets thanks u

    Reply
  9. abhishek rai says

    August 17, 2017 at 10:15 am

    commendable work

    Reply
  10. Kaushal Agrawal says

    November 9, 2017 at 12:09 pm

    Sir/Madam
    Can you please provide information regarding the provisions for by-election of parliament or state legislature in India.

    Reply
  11. Ankita says

    July 13, 2018 at 2:39 pm

    A very good Insight provided, covering every aspect of the topic.

    Reply
  12. Sree Lakshmi Reddy says

    September 2, 2018 at 12:27 pm

    It’s really informative …points covered are very clear.

    Reply
  13. SHARAD SHAH says

    July 6, 2019 at 3:05 pm

    Simultaneous Elections will solve no problem. The root problem of EC is that it is in a seasonal business. Busy for 2 months in 5 years followed by a lean period of 4 years and 10 months.

    This can be changed by dividing 550 parliamentary constituencies into 60 sectior and holding elections in sector once every 5 years.

    The cost will go down by 95% and other problems of constructional amendments and migration will remain.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Aim to be an IAS Officer?

Nothing can beat practice!

Join ClearIAS Prelims Test Series 2021

Practice 40+ online mock exams!

Limited Period Offer: 40% OFF!

Enroll Now!

ClearIAS Study Materials for UPSC Prelims and Mains

  • Indian History - Indian History and Culture.
  • Geography - Indian and World Geography.
  • Economics - Indian Economy.
  • Indian Polity - Constitution, Social Justice etc.
  • General Science - Science and Technology.
  • Environment - Biodiversity, Climate Change etc.
  • Current Affairs - National and international.

ClearIAS Study Materials for UPSC Mains (Extra-Topics)

  • World History - GS paper 1.
  • Indian Society - GS paper 1.
  • Foreign Relations - GS paper 2.
  • International Affairs - GS paper 2.
  • Internal Security - GS paper 3.
  • Disaster Management - GS paper 3.
  • Ethics - GS paper 4.

ClearIAS Study Materials for UPSC Mains (Paper-wise)

  • Essay Paper
  • GS 1 Paper
  • GS 2 Paper
  • GS 3 Paper
  • GS 4 Paper

ClearIAS Online Mock Exams (Prelims and Mains)

  • Prelims Mock Exams
  • Mains Mock Exams (AWP)

Congrats! You are at the right place - ClearIAS!

  • 1 million+ monthly users!
  • 9,00,000+ ClearIAS App Downloads!
  • 4,50,000+ Facebook Followers!
  • 3,50,000+ Email Subscribers!
  • 3,00,000+ Registered Aspirants!

Prepare for UPSC Online!

Get Started

UPSC Online Preparation Guidance

  • UPSC - Union Public Service Commission
  • IAS - Indian Administrative Service
  • Civil Services Exam (CSE) - Exam Pattern
  • UPSC Syllabus - Subjects to learn
  • IAS Books - Books to learn
  • UPSC CSE Eligibility - Who can appear?
  • UPSC Exam Dates - When should you apply?
  • UPSC Result - Check UPSC Results
  • UPSC FAQs - Clarify your queries

What do toppers' say about ClearIAS?

Poonam Dalal

"Working 24*7 in the police for the last 5 years and been out of touch with the preparation, I took the guidance from your website, especially the ClearIAS prelims test series. I bought it and found it to be the best available online." - Poonam Dalal, ClearIAS Online Student

Read more reviews by UPSC Toppers...

Enroll in

ClearIAS UPSC Prelims Online Test Series 2021

Score High in the IAS Exam!

Trusted by Toppers

Limited Period Offer: 40% Discount!

Enroll now

Don’t lose out without playing the right game!

Adopt the 3 Strategies for Success in the UPSC Civil Services Exam.

Learn UPSC Strategies

  • Home
  • IAS
  • UPSC
  • FAQs
  • Blog
  • Login

UPSC Online Preparation

  • Union Public Service Commission (UPSC)
  • Indian Administrative Service (IAS)
  • Indian Police Service (IPS)
  • IAS Exam Eligibility
  • UPSC Free Study Materials
  • UPSC Exam Guidance
  • UPSC Prelims Test Series
  • UPSC Syllabus
  • UPSC Online
  • UPSC Books
  • UPSC Prelims
  • UPSC Mains
  • UPSC Interview

ClearIAS

  • About ClearIAS
  • ClearIAS Programs
  • IAS Coaching
  • Announcements
  • Book Review
  • ClearIAS App
  • Sitemap
  • Work with us
  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact Us

UPSC 2021

UPSC Exam Calendar 2021

Follow us

Follow us on FacebookFollow us on TwitterFollow us on YouTubeFollow us on ClearIAS Learning AppFollow us on ClearIAS Test Prep AppFollow us on Telegram

Featured on

ClearIAS Featured in The Hindu
ClearIAS Featured in the Times of India
ClearIAS Featured in the New Indian Express
ClearIAS Featured in the Yourstory

and many more...

Copyright © 2020 - ClearIAS.com