• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

ClearIAS

UPSC: Latest News, IAS, IPS, UPSC Online Preparation

UPSC Prelims Test Series 2021Enroll Now
  • Home
  • Start
    • IAS
    • IAS Exam Eligibility
    • UPSC
    • UPSC Syllabus
    • UPSC Exam Date
    • UPSC Results
    • FAQs
  • Programs
    • Prelims
    • Mains
    • Interview
  • Buy
    • Courses
    • Mock Test Series
    • IAS Books
    • eBooks (PDF)
  • Free
    • Study Materials
    • Guidance
    • eBooks (PDFs)
    • Mock Exams
    • ClearIAS App
    • Downloads
  • Toppers
  • Blog
  • Login
ClearIAS » Current Affairs Notes » Privatisation of Air India – Should India’s Public Sector Airline be Disinvested?

Privatisation of Air India – Should India’s Public Sector Airline be Disinvested?

Last updated on September 30, 2017 by Clear IAS Team

Air IndiaNITI Aayog recommended for privatisation of Air India and the cabinet committee gave “in-principle” approval for privatising Air India.

But should Air India be disinvested?

In this post, we discuss Indian aviation sector, Air India-Indian Airlines merger, and will see if the reasons for privatisation can be justified or not.

Background of Air India

  • Air India: Air India, formerly named Tata Airlines was founded by JRD Tata. It was renamed as Air India, primarily operating on international routes in 1946.
  • Indian Airlines: Indian Airlines was a major Indian airline based in Delhi and focused primarily on domestic routes, along with several international services to neighbouring countries in Asia. It was administered by the Ministry of Civil Aviation.
  • Air India merged with the erstwhile Indian Airlines in 2007 based on the recommendations of Justice Dharmadhikari committee report.
  • As part of the merger process, a new company called the National Aviation Company of India Limited (now called Air India Limited) was established, into which both Air India and Indian Airlines would be merged.

Air India-Indian Airlines Merger: A failed one?

AI and Indian Airlines had been running profitably till 2005–06. However, their future had already been compromised by then. It is commented that the merger of Air India with Indian Airlines has created woes due to lack of effective leadership and erroneous government policies.

Why were Indian Airlines merged with Air India (2007)?

  • The merger was initiated with the aim of making profits and gaining high market share for the airline. The major objective behind the committee formation was a rationalization of operations and restructuring of debt.
  • Escalating costs of Aviation Turbine Fuel (ATF).
  • Immense competition from private and low-cost airlines.
  • Increased cost pressures due to the acquisition of additional aircraft Leadership crisis due to frequent change of the chairman- cum-managing director.
  • Air India could not fully use the bilateral rights, unlike foreign airlines which took maximum advantage. So it was decided to go for the merger.
  • Declining passenger traffic in the premium class.

Why was the Air India-Indian Airlines merges not successful?

Indian Airlines

  • Air India has had four chairmen in the last six years with no one biting the bullet on tough decisions. The instability at the top has led to poor profits due to lack of decision making.
  • The merger brought together two disparate entities and created a behemoth with 30,517 employees – 221 employees per aircraft, which is much higher than the Singapore Airlines which has 161 and British Airways which has 178. The increase in a number of employees led to pressure in the form of salaries and this further led to more losses. (Reference: Business Today)
  • No attempts were made to standardise hiring policies for the rank and file. Both the partners had different rules and policies which were not harmonized for a smoother run.
  • During the period 1998–2004, no new planes were ordered for AI or Indian Airlines.
  • Because of post merger HR issues like compensation, career progression, and salary payment, promotion issues, and employee strikes, the merger did not yield the intended objectives.
  • The poor management practices and improper planning have pushed the merged entity into trouble.
  • The Parliamentary standing committee on transport, tourism, and culture, in 2010 summarized the problems of the Air India merger process. It said that the first reason for the fall in the morale of the employees was changing the name of IA (Indian Airlines) which had had a good reputation in the market. The reason was not revealed either to customers or to employees by the management.

10-year Restructuring Plan for Air India (2012-2022)

  • In April 2012, the government signed a 10-year restructuring plan with the AI.
  • By April 2012, when the government finally signed on a turnaround plan for AI, the annual operational loss of the airline had increased to around ₹5,000 crore and its accumulated debt had reached nearly ₹43,500 crore. It was then operating on a capital base of ₹3,345 crore (AI 2012).
  • Repeated statements by the MCA in Parliament over the years have testified that the government is largely satisfied that the AI is progressing as per the turnaround plan (MCA 2017a).

Is Air India a loss making company?

Is Air India making profit?

130+ Prelims Marks is Possible. Only if you are guided the right way.

Join ClearIAS Prelims Test Series 2021.

Take a Free Test

The national carrier is one among other airlines that were struggling and is still undergoing a 10-year rehabilitation package that started in 2012.

It posted faster-than-anticipated operating profits and lower net losses in 2015–16, much before its recovery package was to begin bearing fruit, while its low-cost subsidiary Air India Express posted profits.

Both have reportedly done even better in 2016–17.

Air India’s passenger load factor (or its ability to fill seat capacity), a key indicator of airline performance, has improved steadily over the last five years.

The Indian civil aviation sector at large also reported positive results the same year, after a decade of difficulty.

With steady passenger growth, it is expected to be the third largest civil aviation market by the end of the decade. (Reference: EPW)

How correct is to point fingers at the management of Air India for losses?

Air India is not the only airline that was doing badly earlier.

Don't miss the latest updates of ClearIAS!

Join ClearIAS Telegram Chanel.

Get free studymaterials and guidance.

Join for FREE

Private airlines too have had difficulty navigating India’s civil aviation sector.

Around 23 airlines closed or merged with others but the latter eventually shut down, or have ceased operations.

Many of the airlines that continued to operate have reported losses over the past decade.

Until the drop in global crude oil prices, the sector faced difficulties due to relatively higher aviation turbine fuel costs in India, excess capacity, and a limited number of high-traffic routes to vie for.

Criticisms of Privatising Air India

  • The civil aviation market in India, like in many parts of the world, is oligopolistic, with a few firms controlling large market shares.
  • Forcing the exit or merger of an established state-run airline – with the third largest market share by which has 31% of the planes in the sector and prime slots at airports worldwide – will only aid in the undesirable concentration of market power with a few already large private airlines, and will prove anti-competitive.
  • If anything, a public sector enterprise of this size in an oligopolistic sector is not only desirable, but essential.

Way ahead

Instead of indulging in virulent criticism of the Maharaja, the government must allow the recovery package to bear fruit, and must not privatise in haste. All signals – fuel prices and market conditions -suggest that Air India will prove to be a profitable venture for the government like it used to be earlier.

Air India will have to cut layers of management, align staff by role, bring in lateral hires, overhaul customer facing functions, and implement a massive training exercise. And, rein in pilots and engineers, even if it means a partial lockout. Though the process is on track to some extent, still a lot needs to be done in this regard.

Article contributed by Pooja Chaudhary and edited by ClearIAS Team

Trusted by Toppers. Loved by 3,00,000+ Registered Users.

ClearIAS UPSC Prelims Online Mock Exams.

Take a Free Test

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Share505
Tweet
WhatsApp
505 Shares

Integrate Learning With Test-Taking!

Is UPSC Prelims your weak area?

Don’t worry!

We can help you score high marks!

Are you ready to practise the right way?

Yes, I want ClearIAS to help me score high!

Get our newsletter

Don't miss our email updates!

About Clear IAS Team

ClearIAS provides free IAS online coaching, guidance, strategies, books, online study-materials and mock tests with a vision that no candidate should be left out of UPSC exam competition due to in-accessibility of expensive IAS classroom coaching.

We write simple, easy to understand articles, but always ensure high standards of quality.

Rated among the best, emerging online test preparation startups, Clear IAS also offers for free, the popular Clear IAS android app.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Kumaran says

    August 15, 2017 at 10:45 pm

    Very informative!!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Aim to be an IAS Officer?

Nothing can beat practice!

Join ClearIAS Prelims Test Series 2021

Practice 40+ online mock exams!

Limited Period Offer: 40% OFF!

Enroll Now!

ClearIAS Study Materials for UPSC Prelims and Mains

  • Indian History - Indian History and Culture.
  • Geography - Indian and World Geography.
  • Economics - Indian Economy.
  • Indian Polity - Constitution, Social Justice etc.
  • General Science - Science and Technology.
  • Environment - Biodiversity, Climate Change etc.
  • Current Affairs - National and international.

ClearIAS Study Materials for UPSC Mains (Extra-Topics)

  • World History - GS paper 1.
  • Indian Society - GS paper 1.
  • Foreign Relations - GS paper 2.
  • International Affairs - GS paper 2.
  • Internal Security - GS paper 3.
  • Disaster Management - GS paper 3.
  • Ethics - GS paper 4.

ClearIAS Study Materials for UPSC Mains (Paper-wise)

  • Essay Paper
  • GS 1 Paper
  • GS 2 Paper
  • GS 3 Paper
  • GS 4 Paper

ClearIAS Online Mock Exams (Prelims and Mains)

  • Prelims Mock Exams
  • Mains Mock Exams (AWP)

Congrats! You are at the right place - ClearIAS!

  • 1 million+ monthly users!
  • 9,00,000+ ClearIAS App Downloads!
  • 4,50,000+ Facebook Followers!
  • 3,50,000+ Email Subscribers!
  • 3,00,000+ Registered Aspirants!

Prepare for UPSC Online!

Get Started

UPSC Online Preparation Guidance

  • UPSC - Union Public Service Commission
  • IAS - Indian Administrative Service
  • Civil Services Exam (CSE) - Exam Pattern
  • UPSC Syllabus - Subjects to learn
  • IAS Books - Books to learn
  • UPSC CSE Eligibility - Who can appear?
  • UPSC Exam Dates - When should you apply?
  • UPSC Result - Check UPSC Results
  • UPSC FAQs - Clarify your queries

What do toppers' say about ClearIAS?

Poonam Dalal

"Working 24*7 in the police for the last 5 years and been out of touch with the preparation, I took the guidance from your website, especially the ClearIAS prelims test series. I bought it and found it to be the best available online." - Poonam Dalal, ClearIAS Online Student

Read more reviews by UPSC Toppers...

Enroll in

ClearIAS UPSC Prelims Online Test Series 2021

Score High in the IAS Exam!

Trusted by Toppers

Limited Period Offer: 40% Discount!

Enroll now

Don’t lose out without playing the right game!

Adopt the 3 Strategies for Success in the UPSC Civil Services Exam.

Learn UPSC Strategies

  • Home
  • IAS
  • UPSC
  • FAQs
  • Blog
  • Login

UPSC Online Preparation

  • Union Public Service Commission (UPSC)
  • Indian Administrative Service (IAS)
  • Indian Police Service (IPS)
  • IAS Exam Eligibility
  • UPSC Free Study Materials
  • UPSC Exam Guidance
  • UPSC Prelims Test Series
  • UPSC Syllabus
  • UPSC Online
  • UPSC Books
  • UPSC Prelims
  • UPSC Mains
  • UPSC Interview

ClearIAS

  • About ClearIAS
  • ClearIAS Programs
  • IAS Coaching
  • Announcements
  • Book Review
  • ClearIAS App
  • Sitemap
  • Work with us
  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact Us

UPSC 2021

UPSC Exam Calendar 2021

Follow us

Follow us on FacebookFollow us on TwitterFollow us on YouTubeFollow us on ClearIAS Learning AppFollow us on ClearIAS Test Prep AppFollow us on Telegram

Featured on

ClearIAS Featured in The Hindu
ClearIAS Featured in the Times of India
ClearIAS Featured in the New Indian Express
ClearIAS Featured in the Yourstory

and many more...

Copyright © 2020 - ClearIAS.com