• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

ClearIAS

UPSC: Latest News, IAS, IPS, UPSC Online Preparation

UPSC Prelims Test Series 2021Enroll Now
  • Home
  • Start
    • IAS
    • IAS Exam Eligibility
    • UPSC
    • UPSC Syllabus
    • UPSC Exam Date
    • UPSC Results
    • FAQs
  • Programs
    • Prelims
    • Mains
    • Interview
  • Buy
    • Courses
    • Mock Test Series
    • IAS Books
    • eBooks (PDF)
  • Free
    • Study Materials
    • Guidance
    • eBooks (PDFs)
    • Mock Exams
    • ClearIAS App
    • Downloads
  • Toppers
  • Blog
  • Login
ClearIAS » Ethics Notes » Ethics Case Study : Change in Eligibility Criteria

Ethics Case Study : Change in Eligibility Criteria

Last updated on May 18, 2016 by Alex Andrews George

Ethics Case Study No 3 by ClearIAS.com related to Ethics, Integrity and Aptitude (Civil Services Mains Paper 5): Readers can post answers in the comment-space provided.

Ethics Case Study No 3 : Change in Eligibility Criteria

Question: You are the entrance exam commissioner for conducting Medical Entrance Tests. As per Government norms a few seats are reserved for students from economically backward sections. The criteria for economic backwardness is family income. Those students whose family income is below 4 lakhs per annum, based on merit, will qualify for the mentioned seats. Students are asked to declare their family income while filing application. 

Ethics

When you published the final rank list after the exam, you get a call from the concerned minister. He presents before you a special case of his relative. While filing the application, his relative gave family income declaration as 6 Lakhs as his parent was working then. But two months after filing the application the parent retired from service and now the family income is only 3 lakh per annum. The student is bright, but will get admission only if gets the economic backwardness quota.

The Minister asks you not to stick too much to rules and give the benefit of family income to the student, by treating this as a special case. 

Is there any thing unethical in the minister’s demand? What will be your approach to this case?

130+ Prelims Marks is Possible. Only if you are guided the right way.

Join ClearIAS Prelims Test Series 2021.

Take a Free Test

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Share
Tweet
WhatsApp

Integrate Learning With Test-Taking!

Is UPSC Prelims your weak area?

Don’t worry!

We can help you score high marks!

Are you ready to practise the right way?

Yes, I want ClearIAS to help me score high!

Get our newsletter

Don't miss our email updates!

About Alex Andrews George

Alex Andrews George is a mentor, author, and entrepreneur. Alex is the founder of ClearIAS and one of the expert Civil Service Exam Trainers in India.

He is the author of many best-seller books like 'Important Judgments that transformed India' and 'Important Acts that transformed India'.

A trusted mentor and pioneer in online training, Alex's guidance, strategies, study-materials, and mock-exams have helped thousands of aspirants to become IAS, IPS, and IFS officers.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Sumit Singh says

    July 31, 2016 at 6:39 pm

    I think minister’s demand is unethical. Because as per the details provided in the application form, that student does not belong to the economical backward category. There could be many students who have the same case as the politician’s relative. So, this case should not be considered as a special case, as it will be injustice and discrimination to other students.

    I will try to explain to the politician that this is unethical and unlawful to consider it as a special case, as the rules don’t permit for it.

    Reply
  2. Soumya Datta says

    October 8, 2016 at 8:01 pm

    first thing, i will mention while making rules that special cases will be considered. So it will be ethical to consider such cases.

    Reply
  3. cool guy says

    November 9, 2016 at 7:42 pm

    firstly there must be a mention of final interpreting authority for special cases (like supreme court for Indian constitution), in this case I am that authority, at my discretion i will consider it as a special case but only this case I will prepare almost all possible special cases which are likely to be happen in future, this particular is forwarded by minister because student is his relative it can be kinda nepotism or partisanship on my head which is against the spirit of bureaucracy. I will put a notice on website mentioning almost all possible special cases to be consider by commission for recruitment and for this case I will ask for a written letter from minister which can be used as an evidence in future by department.

    Reply
  4. bijay kumar jena says

    November 29, 2016 at 2:32 pm

    first of all i will check the provision of amendment in financial certificate after submitting final application form. this the first step toward deciding the case is ethical or unethical.

    i will go through the proper way because i never want to give any wrong reply of RTI application of any candidate.

    Reply
  5. Mohit says

    December 15, 2019 at 4:27 pm

    As a holding a responsible office of exam commissioner, I would chose to go by the rules. Yes certainly, minister could be convinced that the income criterion is not for the future income. But the current income at the time of filling up of the application form. If someone’s income reduces or increases that doest not have retrospective impact in the application process.
    As a responsible person its the duty of exam commissioner to make sure the selection process of the entrance test is fair for everyone after all it is the fundamental right of all Indian citizens. No one should be deprived of this right in any circumstances.
    The candidate proposed by the minister might be bright but there must be even brighter candidate in accordance of the due process of the entrance exam and hence the merit based selection should prevail.
    I am sure by this a minister could be convinced to adhere with the process and not to circumvent it.

    Reply
  6. Mohit says

    December 15, 2019 at 4:31 pm

    if you are reading it, please help to provide feedback. I thank you in advance.

    Reply
  7. Rohtak Singh says

    September 13, 2020 at 12:23 pm

    The ministers case can not be taken as exception as myself being a Exam Director I have the responsibility of being fair and unbiased. Preserving the essence of constitution, ethics and morality I would not agree with the minister’s fact and will continue making the list as per the merit of students.

    Reply
  8. Vijayalakshmi D says

    January 28, 2021 at 9:05 am

    The demand of minister is unethical. Apart from minister’s demand, there is a opportunity to look into student background to full fill the criteria.
    Even background class family income may change(increase) if they change their job.
    In this case, background family income will comes under within 3lakh once they retired and student is bright and chance to come in merit list.
    Then, we can consider this as a special case as there is a opportunity in the constitution. And no need to spoil the bright student future in the name of strict moral exam commissioner. Instead we can give opportunity to talented student by considering this as a special case.
    Hence, we need to look into student’s future and background of family while considering as a special case but no need to consider special case for all the recommendation.

    Reply
  9. Bala says

    February 1, 2021 at 8:50 am

    A non-creamy layer person may get creamy layer position during application process. In this situation he will definitely benefit by his family background whether he got selected by the application process or not. Similarly every person gets down their financial position like given case, also get worse after the process. As the Authority of the whole selecting process, I can make change in the process to re apply the students who are in the same case after I requested from politician. Then this opportunity will be helpful for the needy candidates.
    But, as per my own ethical basis, the recommended candidate is well settled these days by his family financial position so far. By this situation he may got many chances to engage himself to forward. The same case is not for others who may felt many struggles to come this stage. So I will give any favor to no one.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Aim to be an IAS Officer?

Nothing can beat practice!

Join ClearIAS Prelims Test Series 2021

Practice 40+ online mock exams!

Limited Period Offer: 40% OFF!

Enroll Now!

ClearIAS Study Materials for UPSC Prelims and Mains

  • Indian History - Indian History and Culture.
  • Geography - Indian and World Geography.
  • Economics - Indian Economy.
  • Indian Polity - Constitution, Social Justice etc.
  • General Science - Science and Technology.
  • Environment - Biodiversity, Climate Change etc.
  • Current Affairs - National and international.

ClearIAS Study Materials for UPSC Mains (Extra-Topics)

  • World History - GS paper 1.
  • Indian Society - GS paper 1.
  • Foreign Relations - GS paper 2.
  • International Affairs - GS paper 2.
  • Internal Security - GS paper 3.
  • Disaster Management - GS paper 3.
  • Ethics - GS paper 4.

ClearIAS Study Materials for UPSC Mains (Paper-wise)

  • Essay Paper
  • GS 1 Paper
  • GS 2 Paper
  • GS 3 Paper
  • GS 4 Paper

ClearIAS Online Mock Exams (Prelims and Mains)

  • Prelims Mock Exams
  • Mains Mock Exams (AWP)

Congrats! You are at the right place - ClearIAS!

  • 1 million+ monthly users!
  • 9,00,000+ ClearIAS App Downloads!
  • 4,50,000+ Facebook Followers!
  • 3,50,000+ Email Subscribers!
  • 3,00,000+ Registered Aspirants!

Prepare for UPSC Online!

Get Started

UPSC Online Preparation Guidance

  • UPSC - Union Public Service Commission
  • IAS - Indian Administrative Service
  • Civil Services Exam (CSE) - Exam Pattern
  • UPSC Syllabus - Subjects to learn
  • IAS Books - Books to learn
  • UPSC CSE Eligibility - Who can appear?
  • UPSC Exam Dates - When should you apply?
  • UPSC Result - Check UPSC Results
  • UPSC FAQs - Clarify your queries

What do toppers' say about ClearIAS?

Poonam Dalal

"Working 24*7 in the police for the last 5 years and been out of touch with the preparation, I took the guidance from your website, especially the ClearIAS prelims test series. I bought it and found it to be the best available online." - Poonam Dalal, ClearIAS Online Student

Read more reviews by UPSC Toppers...

Enroll in

ClearIAS UPSC Prelims Online Test Series 2021

Score High in the IAS Exam!

Trusted by Toppers

Limited Period Offer: 40% Discount!

Enroll now

Don’t lose out without playing the right game!

Adopt the 3 Strategies for Success in the UPSC Civil Services Exam.

Learn UPSC Strategies

  • Home
  • IAS
  • UPSC
  • FAQs
  • Blog
  • Login

UPSC Online Preparation

  • Union Public Service Commission (UPSC)
  • Indian Administrative Service (IAS)
  • Indian Police Service (IPS)
  • IAS Exam Eligibility
  • UPSC Free Study Materials
  • UPSC Exam Guidance
  • UPSC Prelims Test Series
  • UPSC Syllabus
  • UPSC Online
  • UPSC Books
  • UPSC Prelims
  • UPSC Mains
  • UPSC Interview

ClearIAS

  • About ClearIAS
  • ClearIAS Programs
  • IAS Coaching
  • Announcements
  • Book Review
  • ClearIAS App
  • Sitemap
  • Work with us
  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact Us

UPSC 2021

UPSC Exam Calendar 2021

Follow us

Follow us on FacebookFollow us on TwitterFollow us on YouTubeFollow us on ClearIAS Learning AppFollow us on ClearIAS Test Prep AppFollow us on Telegram

Featured on

ClearIAS Featured in The Hindu
ClearIAS Featured in the Times of India
ClearIAS Featured in the New Indian Express
ClearIAS Featured in the Yourstory

and many more...

Copyright © 2020 - ClearIAS.com