Pamir Karakoram Anomaly

The Pamir Karakoram Anomaly is being studied by scientists as it is a climate puzzle in a warming world. Read here to learn more about it.

Scientists are currently analysing deep ice cores from the Kon-Chukurbashi ice cap in Tajikistan to better understand the Pamir Karakoram anomaly, a rare climatic phenomenon where glaciers have remained stable or even grown despite accelerating global warming.

This research is crucial for improving glacier-climate models and understanding regional water security in High Asia.

What is the Pamir Karakoram Anomaly?

The Pamir Karakoram anomaly refers to the unusual stability or slight mass gain of glaciers in the Karakoram Range and parts of the Pamir Mountains since the late 20th century.

This behaviour contrasts sharply with:

Don't miss ClearIAS updates: Add ClearIAS as a preferred source on Google Add →

• Rapid glacier retreat in the Himalayas
• Shrinkage in the Alps, Andes, and Rocky Mountains

While most mountain glaciers worldwide are losing mass due to rising temperatures, Karakoram glaciers have shown near-zero mass balance or marginal growth, making this region an outlier in global cryospheric trends.

Geographical Extent

• Core region: Karakoram Range (Gilgit-Baltistan, parts of Ladakh)
• Extended zone: Western Pamirs (Tajikistan, Afghanistan)
• Hydrological importance: Headwaters of the Indus River system

Proposed Scientific Explanations

The anomaly is not due to the absence of warming, but rather a unique interaction of climate, topography, and glaciology.

1. Increased Winter Precipitation

• Glaciers receive heavy snowfall during winter, replenishing ice mass.
• Snowfall offsets summer melting, unlike monsoon-dominated Himalayas.

2. Dominance of Western Disturbances

• Moisture primarily comes from Western Disturbances, not the Indian monsoon.
• Winter snowfall is more effective for glacier mass balance than summer rain.

3. High and Steep Topography

• Extremely high elevations provide large accumulation zones above the melting threshold.
• Steep slopes reduce the residence time of meltwater, limiting surface melt.

4. Summer Cloud Cover

• Increased cloudiness reduces incoming solar radiation.
• Lower short-wave radiation suppresses ablation during summer.

5. Protective Debris Cover

• Thick debris layers act as thermal insulation, reducing ice melt at lower elevations.
• Unlike thin debris (which accelerates melt), thick debris slows it significantly.

Recent Scientific Findings

• Satellite altimetry (ICESat-2) and gravity data (GRACE) indicate that:
  • The anomaly has weakened in recent years
  • Some Karakoram glaciers are now showing early signs of mass loss
• Ice-core drilling in Pamir ice caps (like Kon-Chukurbashi) aims to:
  • Reconstruct past snowfall and temperature patterns
  • Understand long-term glacier-climate interactions beyond satellite records

Field-based ice-core evidence is crucial because satellites provide only recent, surface-level trends, while ice cores reveal multi-decadal to centennial climate history.

Why is this Anomaly Important for India?

1. Water Security

• Karakoram glaciers feed the Indus River and its tributaries
• Relative glacier stability ensures:
  • More predictable river flows
  • Reduced risk of abrupt water shortages in Ladakh and Jammu & Kashmir

2. Climate Risk Assessment

• Demonstrates that glacier response to warming is region-specific
• Challenges to one-size-fits-all climate models for the Himalayan cryosphere

3. Disaster Management

• Stable glaciers reduce the immediate risks of:
  • Glacial Lake Outburst Floods (GLOFs)
  • Sudden meltwater surges
• However, a weakening anomaly may increase future hazards

The Karakoram Range

• Location: Central Asia
• Neighbouring systems:
  • Hindu Kush (west)
  • Pamirs (north-west)
  • Kunlun Mountains (north-east)
  • Himalayas (south-east)
• Countries: India, Pakistan, China, Afghanistan, Tajikistan
• Highest peak: K2 (8,611 m), second-highest in the world

Broader Implications

• The anomaly shows that global warming does not produce uniform outcomes
• Regional climate drivers (wind systems, precipitation type, terrain) matter
• Weakening of the anomaly suggests no glacier system is immune to sustained warming

Conclusion

The Pamir Karakoram anomaly represents a rare but fragile exception in a warming world. Ongoing ice-core studies from the Pamirs are essential to decode why these glaciers resisted global trends and why that resistance may now be fading.

For India, understanding this anomaly is vital for long-term water security, climate adaptation, and Himalayan policy planning. As climate change accelerates, even these resilient glaciers may not remain insulated for long.

Related articles:

• Glaciers in India
• Himalayas
• Glacial retreat